I’m grateful for my wife’s dementia​

Contact Keith Eldred, Hollidaysburg, PA, red@thisis.red
Please see downloadable images within the article

This article was updated July 25, 2022

I’m grateful for my wife Janet’s dementia.

Did I just say that? I’m grateful that her mind is failing?

Well, look. You have a problem, you choose how to respond. I choose to appreciate the positives, including how Janet’s condition led us to an inspiring $1 million project for our public library. More about that shortly. First I’ll give specifics about Janet, because dementia follows many different paths.

Something went wrong with her brain well before age 60, on top of what had always been wrong: chronic depression and anxiety. These have long been treated and never held her back. She was an honor student right through grad school; an active church member; a long-time corporate manager; and for the final 18 years of her career, she was the director of our local public library, her service prized by the board of directors. She is a loving, attentive mother and wife, patient but with high expectations. For the first 25 years of her marriage, she handled all of our home finances.

Janet’s dementia has no precipitating event such as concussion or surgery. We think that stress contributed, as well as a cardiac condition that eventually came to lightbradycardia, random drops in heart rate that deprive the brain of oxygen. Whatever the underlying reasons, Janet no longer forms memories reliably, and she’s lost much of what had been stored: our wedding, graduations, the funerals of her father and mine, trips around the country, wading in the Jordan River with her mother, and much more.

Yet I’m grateful for Janet’s dementia.

I am NOT glad that she’s forgetting. Memory is not only a comfort in retrieving yesterdays, it’s a personal adviser that guides you places, advises you on work procedures, and saves you from repeating discussions with your spouse about bank balances, home maintenance, and operating your Kindle. (insert sigh) Janet’s memory problem is my problem, too.

But you get used to it. Just like someone gets used to a partner’s losing a hand, becoming lactose-intolerant, or acquiring an ugly tattoo. However, I am not just accustomed to Janet’s dementia, I’m grateful for it.

I’m grateful for my wife’s dementia because there are upsides. I’m only half-joking. Me: “Dear, you forgot about my burning the pizza? Tracking mud onto your clean floor? Bleaching your favorite sweatshirt? Or that you had a favorite sweatshirt?” Hey, I can work with this.

I’m grateful for my wife’s dementia because it could be something worse. There are stiffer misfortunes for sure. When I witness someone else’s trial, I often think that Janet and I have it easier. Virtually always.

I’m grateful for my wife’s dementia because it is within a lifetime of blessings. It’s just yellow snow. That’s how I think of it. A blizzard passes and leaves a blanket of white, the sun turning your lawn into a field of diamonds, and one little patch shows that a dog has lifted his leg. You’re going to get upset about that? Look at the diamonds! Piss cannot dissolve diamonds.

Janet and I have diamonds. Our sons and daughters-in-law and granddaughters—three of each—are bright, shining, multi-faceted gems. Our home during all of our married life is a short walk from a town square called The Diamond. We love this town. Our neighbors are friendly, our church is here, the boys’ schools are here. They all played baseball here … on diamonds!

In fall of 2020, we reached our 30th anniversary, and the gift for that milestone is a diamond. Janet doesn’t have one, but if that ever crosses her mind, she soon forgets, < rim shot > and now we’ve passed 31 years, so it’s too late anyway.

I’m grateful for my wife’s dementia because we can joke about it. Like I just did! I know what I can and cannot josh about with Janet. Never mice. She hates mice and never forgets that. Mice are what I’m taking care not to mention right now. But memory jokes are fine. Laughter helps.

I’m grateful for my wife’s dementia because it gives a reason to spotlight her. I am proud to tell Janet’s story, both present and past. Her response to the disease shows the same spirit that let her ace graduate school in her late forties, earning her Master’s in Library & Information Science in the nation’s earliest wave of online students (also with time on site at the University of Pittsburgh)(Her undergrad was at Penn State, so she nails both sides of that bitter school rivalry). Then she went on to build our new public library building.

Previous and current library buildings

I say that with only slight exaggeration. When Janet became the director of our library, it occupied a 36-year-old building with limited accessibility and no room to grow. The children’s room was in the basement: Safe and clean but windowless. After an exhausting capital campaign and building project lasting 11 years, the Library moved to a beautiful new $2.8 million facility with 80% more space, over double the parking, and complete accessibility—on time, under budget and mortgage-free. Not to take away from the active board and campaign chair, but all day-to-day matters for the campaign flowed through Janet, including every grant application and fundraising mailing. She put in more hours than anyone else to complete the project. She is a hero.

My favorite detail in the finished building is the placement of the interior signs. Janet delegated this to me, and I set them all at her height of 5 foot 1, rather than the standard 5 feet. The signs are one Janet high because in that library, she literally was (wait for it) the ruler.

But she was a benevolent ruler and down to earth. I also mean “down to earth” literally: When the job demanded it, Janet got dirty sweeping, shoveling, or lugging books. In the library booth at outdoor festivals, she stuck it out rain, shine or cold. Then she’d thaw out, clean up, dry off and go give a talk to the Rotary Club. That is why the library board continued to treasure her after she came out about her dementia.

I’m grateful for my wife’s dementia because of our learnings about it. Is a frightening health condition worth the knowledge that you gain? Well, at least it’s some compensation. It’s enriching to better understand a particular corner of existence.

Now we know up close what dementia can look and feel like. Janet first sensed problems about eight years into her library career. It began with uncertain thinking that we initially attributed to stress and expected to fade after the building project. But what faded was her memory and other mental functions.

Janet’s first cognitive test with a psychologist was abysmal. She could not repeat back short lists of words or name more than a few items starting with the letter “F.” She had trouble connecting dots using a super-tricky sequence such as 1-A-2-B-3-C. She started forgetting to keep appointments and then, afterward, forgetting the ones that she did keep. I’d go with her to a doctor visit or a movie, and a week later she would recall nothing about it.

I’m grateful for my wife’s dementia because it brings us unique delights. On one special car trip, Janet gave me a great gift. For three hours, she happily let me recount the entire plot of a long novel that I had written and she had already read. The story was all new to her. (More on that novel shortly.) She also repeatedly watched me perform a one-man play that I wrote, seeing it for the first time five times! The play includes a long poem about her, so that was a handful of nice surprises. I cannot return the same gift. On days when she tells me one story three times, I cut her off.

I’m grateful for my wife’s dementia because it shows her resilience. Janet keeps bouncing back from losses such as no longer being able to drive. This is not only due to concern about confusion, but because she began to have seizures, during which she goes vacant (this is now mostly controlled by medicine). On rare occasions, she blacks out completely and collapses. Doctors tell us that seizures and blackouts are not typical of dementia. This was just bonus neurological fun (or possibly cardiac) that confirmed that Janet’s driving days were over.

I’m able to make light of this now, but giving up driving was a blow to Janet’s sense of self. During the weeks after that decision, she lost 25 pounds. A few of those returned. Slowly, she leveled off emotionally. Now she’s a gracious passenger who doesn’t look back. (Well, rarely. She does still miss the wheel.)

I’m grateful for my wife’s dementia because it has progressed slowly. This is a bright silver lining. Dementia is taking its time with her, and Janet has been able to keep working. At first, we could not conceive of that. She stayed strong on routine daily situations but became wobbly with people or matters that she encounters infrequently, including long-time acquaintances and workplace processes that arose only quarterly or annually. Don’t ask about the circulation desk at the library. Occasionally that duty fell to Janet, and she had to start virtually from scratch, with little understanding of the procedures. With obstacles such as these, how could Janet continue?

She simply came to realize that she could. Completing each day taught her that she could complete each day. Making it through another week, another month, another season … showed her that she could make it through. And not just squeeze by, but continue to help keep the library strong. In the final years of her leadership, the Library installed new memorials indoors and out, including a sculpture and butterfly garden; upgraded dozens of pieces of furniture; and saw healthy increases in its savings.

And yet Janet battled dread of somehow causing harm. It took time to regain confidence that, even at a fraction of her former self, she was still the best person to run our public library. The board of directors was thrilled to keep her on, and they gladly made accommodation by increasing particular duties of one staff member. At Janet’s request, part of her own salary was transferred to this helpful coworker. It took lots of sticky note reminders, but Janet was able to keep on keeping on right up until her retirement in summer of 2022.

I’m grateful for my wife’s dementia because it made us join forces in a new way. Now on many days, I go to work with Janet. I retired early, after 29 years at the same corporation, to pursue a moonshot project with Janet: Raising $1 million for her library. It’s a big challenge that we made all the bigger by aiming to do it with proceeds from my debut novel, the one that Janet read and then forgot. (Well, one of many books that she has read and then forgot.) I have been writing forever but have been published only in limited ways, in our local newspaper and limited forays into self-publishing. It had long been at the top of my bucket list to make a strong run at building an audience. I should say our bucket list, because Janet also wants me to have more readers. Her condition accelerated our plans. Someday became today. We didn’t want to look back and wish we had used time differently.

Eventually, I decided to promote that novel within an entire line of books that happen to tie together by being related to Christmas. I landed on that strategy because self-publishing experts recommend building a following with multiple works. The goal became to publish 20 books in 2020, with all of the profits benefiting the library. Using both past and new writing, I completed all 20, and they are all live on Amazon.

Aside from raising our sons, Janet and I have worked on nothing more important than this endeavor for our public library. The project is online at www.thisis.red, and we call it “This is RED.” That has multiple meanings.

For one thing, that first novel is titled “Red” in Latin: Rubrum. It’s a good long novel, if I do say. Early readers have received it warmly. Now I have the challenge of turning it into a bestseller to generate income for my wife’s library, along with the other books. This article is meant to help spread the word.

Released on the Eldred’s 30th wedding anniversary

This is RED is a shared calling and destiny for Janet and me. I am now working full-time in my art because of her condition. She made it possible. I would not be pursuing my passion this way unless motivated by love for her and by our mutual esteem for books and libraries.

This is the last big thing I want in life. Janet and I hit the jackpot in marriage, family and career. She is giving me my best chance at my final desire: Building an audience for a meaningful book. Her brokenness is making me whole.

I’m grateful for my wife’s dementia because it is making us reach for new connections. I’m trying to draw attention to the work and connect with readers. Part of this attempt is providing entertainment around the theme “This is RED.” It’s amusing to offer T-shirts and other merchandise printed “This is RED” whether or not the item is red. (See our shirts in the pictures above? You can get yours here.)

Our social media includes a daily graphic that plays with RED as an acronym. Examples: A toddler and his teddy bear have a Respectful, Earnest Discussion … a match is shown in three phases: Roaring, Ember, Dead … the Bible story of Goliath is labeled “Rival Encounters David.” So far this string of acronyms has surpassed 650 in total. See them at thisis.red/daily or on social media @thisisdotred.

Examples of the Daily RED


I’m grateful for my wife’s dementia because it is made her a video star. We post occasional videos on YouTube and on Facebook. My big sister Tina insisted that videos are a vital means of telling our story. She was right. Janet and I take pride in depicting our experience. We know that our videos will strike a chord with other dementia patients, caregivers and extended families.

Creating the videos has been one of the best surprises of the project. Despite being a shy librarian, Janet likes making them. She is relaxed and natural in front of the camera, beaming earnestness and utter lack of guile. I declare her America’s new middle-aged sweetheart. The videos capture why I fell in love with her. I feel more attached than ever.

Meet America’s new middle-aged sweetheart

I’m grateful for my wife’s dementia because it has given us more of each other. I am grateful for our new life. I am grateful I am there in the mornings to make Janet oatmeal. I am grateful I am there to drive her on errands. I am grateful I am there when she emerges from a seizure or blackout.

Don’t get me wrong: This is not continuous happiness. Janet can be a pain in my bliss, and vice-versa. That has always been the case. Even a perfect partner is often the enemy you adore.

But the rough times are only patches of yellow snow. So I’m thankful for them, too.

These are good days. Not easy, but good. Now that we’re both retired, money is tight, but that’s not all bad. We have ice cream less but enjoy it more. Please note: All project profits go to the Library, with no income to us.

We have a long way to go but are proud of how far we’ve come. The total to date has surpassed $70,000. This includes a $10,000 national recognitionthe American Library Association Lemony Snicket Prize for Noble Librarians Facing Adversity, which Janet turned over to the library in full. 

The work is slow and hard, but that’s also good. When you ache to make progress before it’s too late, everything you do matters. Our life could not be more full of meaning.

Life is better now. Before, I was fitting Janet around my work. Now I am working around her, for her, and with her. Her condition got us here. This is why I’m grateful for my wife’s dementia.

This article condenses the story told in our memoir.

Janet Eldred is a former bookstore executive whose career concluded with 18 years as library director. Keith Eldred is a writer, designer, marketing professional and long-time library volunteer. Janet has early-stage dementia. She and Keith are aiming to raise $1 million for Janet’s library while she can still contribute. Their website www.thisis.red presents a plan to donate all profits from 20 books that Keith self-published in 2020, the year that he and Janet celebrated 30 years of marriage. Direct contributions to the Hollidaysburg Area Public Library are also welcome. A donation link is at www.thisis.red/donate.

Join our quest

to raise $1 million the hard, fun way

Get four free books now, plus future offers & project updates